Our rankings are cleverly generated from the algorithmic analysis of thousands of customer reviews about products, brands, merchant's customer service levels, popularity trends, and more. The rankings reflect our opinion and should be a good starting point for shopping. As an Amazon Associate we may earn from qualifying purchases. We may receive a commission from purchases made through links on our site, which will help us continue to provide you with value.
Mystery Categories
Best Choice Audible 
The Blackout Murders: A Homefront Sleuths Mystery (The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series, Book 1) Audible The Blackout Murders: A Homefront Sleuths Mystery (The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series, Book 1) 
$50 Electronics Mystery Box Set Get ready for a surprise with this $50 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products. Packed in a box, this collBest Value Audible 
Accidental Magic: Myrtlewood Mysteries, Book 1 
$50 Electronics Mystery Box Set Audible Accidental Magic: Myrtlewood Mysteries, Book 1 
Where the Veil is Thin: A Sapphic Paranormal Cozy Mystery $200 Electronics Mystery Box Set Whether you're looking to expand your own collection or searching for that perfect gift, this mystery box promises a delWhere the Veil is Thin: A Sapphic Paranormal Cozy Mystery $50 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products Bear & King Publishing The Jack Rogan Mysteries Series Boxset: Books 1-3 Bear & King Publishing The Jack Rogan Mysteries Series Boxset: Books 1-3 NeeDoh Easter Golden Egg Hunt Mystery (10 Squishy Surprises!) Toy Gift The NeeDoh Golden Egg Hunt is a fun and interactive Easter decoration from Schylling. This toy is designed for various aTHE LAST WITNESS: A Small Town Witness Protection Mystery (THE LAST WITNESSES MYSTERY SERIES Book 1) Crazy Fun Rainbow Mystery Squishy Bun Dumpling PINK GLITTER VIRAL With a character family of Squishy Bun, this toy is sure to delight children aged 3-4 years with its interactive and engTHE LAST WITNESS: A Small Town Witness Protection Mystery (THE LAST WITNESSES MYSTERY SERIES Book 1) $10 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products Get ready for a surprise with this $10 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products. Each box contains a varietRed AdeptPublishing, LLC April's Fool (A Sam Cable Mystery Book 1) Pokemon TCG Mystery Box *Read Description* Elite Trainer Box. Booster Box. Chance to Get. Graded Slabs. 10 Ultra Rare Cards or Higher.Red AdeptPublishing, LLC April's Fool (A Sam Cable Mystery Book 1) $100 ➕ Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products For Family Value of item is reflective of this. Item will arrive in either a box or satchel. Mystery Box/Satchel. The real colour oHollis Thatcher Press, LTD. Springtime is for MURDER (Killer Cozy Mystery Boxed Set) NeeDoh Easter Golden Egg Hunt Mystery (10 Squishy Surprises!) Toy Gift The NeeDoh Golden Egg Hunt is a fun and interactive Easter decoration from Schylling. This toy is designed for various aHollis Thatcher Press, LTD. Springtime is for MURDER (Killer Cozy Mystery Boxed Set) NeeDoh Easter Golden Egg Hunt Mystery (10 Squishy Surprises!) Toy Gift The NeeDoh Golden Egg Hunt is a fun and interactive Easter decoration from Schylling. This toy is designed for various aJammed (A Charlie Cooper Mystery, Volume 1) MYSTERY PACK 💎 PSA 10 PIKACHU EX SAR 234/193 PACK CHASE 🍀 - (GUARANTEED HIT) THIS IS A FUN MYSTERY PACK WITH A CHANCE FOR A DIAMOND PACK WICH INCLUDES THE PINK PIKACHU CHASE SAR 234/193 . PURCHASINJammed (A Charlie Cooper Mystery, Volume 1) $69 POKEMON MYSTERY BOX - 1x GRADED CARD + 1x RAW/SEALED PROMO CARD 90% of grades will be on average 9-10. We strive to provide you not only great value, but a fun experience.Ava Strong First Kill (A Layla Caine Mystery Book 1) $25 Mystery Box Set of Assorted Lucky Dip Random Products 5Grab yourself a $25 Mystery Box Set filled with an assortment of lucky dip products, perfect for those who love a surprFive Minute Middle Grade Mysteries Volume 1 (Solve It Yourself Mysteries) 50 Pcs Mystery Makeup Bundle Mixed Brands Unveil your potential as a makeup artist with this diverse collection that caters to all skin tones and occasions, makinFive Minute Middle Grade Mysteries Volume 1 (Solve It Yourself Mysteries) Tule Publishing Paws, Claws, and Curses (A Purr-fect Relic Cozy Mystery Book 1) Tule Publishing Paws, Claws, and Curses (A Purr-fect Relic Cozy Mystery Book 1) Mountain Brook Ink Make Haste Slowly (Short Creek Mysteries Book 1) Mountain Brook Ink Make Haste Slowly (Short Creek Mysteries Book 1) Red Adept Publishing, LLC The Cantaloupe Thief (A Branigan Powers Mystery Book 1) Red Adept Publishing, LLC The Cantaloupe Thief (A Branigan Powers Mystery Book 1) Tule Publishing Still Life and Death (The Shepherd Sisters Mysteries Book 3) Tule Publishing Someone Murderous at The Midnight Motel: Female Sleuth Cozy Mysteries (The Accidental Detective Book 5) Roundheels Press The Money Shot: A Danny Diamond Erotic Mystery (Book 1) (Danny Diamond Erotic Mysteries) Roundheels Press The Money Shot: A Danny Diamond Erotic Mystery (Book 1) (Danny Diamond Erotic Mysteries) Vinci Books Cold Comfort: a mystery thriller with twists (Bridgette Cash Mystery Thriller Book 1) Vinci Books Cold Comfort: a mystery thriller with twists (Bridgette Cash Mystery Thriller Book 1) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Mystery of the Missing Book: A cozy crime mystery set in an English village (The Antique Shop Mysteries Book 1) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense The Mystery of the Missing Book: A cozy crime mystery set in an English village (The Antique Shop Mysteries Book 1) Willow Creek Mystery: The Hidden Key : ( A Cozy Mystery of Lost Secrets, Hidden Chambers and a Town's Forgotten Past) ( Willow Creek Mystery: The Hidden Key : ( A Cozy Mystery of Lost Secrets, Hidden Chambers and a Town's Forgotten Past) ( The Strawberry Social: A Small Town Culinary Cozy Mystery (Recipe for Revenge Mysteries Book 1) The Strawberry Social: A Small Town Culinary Cozy Mystery (Recipe for Revenge Mysteries Book 1) The Book Publishing Pros The Law Of Revenge (A Priestly Mystery Book 3) The Book Publishing Pros The Law Of Revenge (A Priestly Mystery Book 3) Audible The Silence at Mystery Bay: A Thomas Austin Crime Thriller, Book 8 Audible The Silence at Mystery Bay: A Thomas Austin Crime Thriller, Book 8 Empress Books Mystic Pieces: a small town paranormal cozy mystery with a reluctant sleuth (Shady Grove Psychic Mystery Book 1) Willow Creek Mystery: The Beginning: (A Cozy Small Town Mystery with Secrets, Clues, and a Clever Cat) (Willow Creek Boo Willow Creek Mystery: The Beginning: (A Cozy Small Town Mystery with Secrets, Clues, and a Clever Cat) (Willow Creek Boo Bookouture A Body on the Doorstep: A completely gripping historical cozy murder mystery (London Ladies' Murder Club Book 1) Hummingword Press Bloom & Buried (Wisteria & Wildwood Apothecary Cozy Mysteries Book 1) Hummingword Press Bloom & Buried (Wisteria & Wildwood Apothecary Cozy Mysteries Book 1) Audible Murder in the Crypt: A Redmond and Haze Mystery, Book 1 Audible Murder in the Crypt: A Redmond and Haze Mystery, Book 1 Willow Creek Mystery: Secrets in the Shadows: ( A Cozy Mystery of Hidden Passages, Secrets Societies and Small Town Secr Willow Creek Mystery: Secrets in the Shadows: ( A Cozy Mystery of Hidden Passages, Secrets Societies and Small Town Secr Bookouture Don't Let Her Go: An absolutely unputdownable, heart-pounding and twisty mystery and suspense thriller (Detective Billie Death on the Front Page: A British Cozy Mystery with a Pet Magpie. (The Bramblewick Gazette Mysteries Series Book 1) Death on the Front Page: A British Cozy Mystery with a Pet Magpie. (The Bramblewick Gazette Mysteries Series Book 1) Murder Most Collectible: (A Miles Beckett Vintage Toy Mystery — Book One) (Miles Beckett Vintage Toy Mystery Series 1) Murder Most Collectible: (A Miles Beckett Vintage Toy Mystery — Book One) (Miles Beckett Vintage Toy Mystery Series 1) Joffe Books crime thriller and mystery MAN ON ICE an action-packed, high-octane thriller Joffe Books crime thriller and mystery MAN ON ICE an action-packed, high-octane thriller Shelved for Good: A Tails Between The Shelves Mystery (Tails Between The Shelves Mysteries) Shelved for Good: A Tails Between The Shelves Mystery (Tails Between The Shelves Mysteries) Raiders of the Lost Hex (Crescent Moon Mysteries Book 7) Raiders of the Lost Hex (Crescent Moon Mysteries Book 7) Blake Pierce When You're Mine (A Finn Wright Mystery Book 1) Fiona Grace Beachfront Bakery: A Killer Cupcake (A Beachfront Bakery Cozy Mystery Book 1) Audible Cozy Witch Mysteries: Special Edition Box Set of 8 Books: Angela Pepper Box Sets and Bundles Audible Cozy Witch Mysteries: Special Edition Box Set of 8 Books: Angela Pepper Box Sets and Bundles Murder at the Boat Rally: A Narrowboat Festival Mystery of Rival Restorers (Kettle & Knot Mysteries Book 2) Murder at the Boat Rally: A Narrowboat Festival Mystery of Rival Restorers (Kettle & Knot Mysteries Book 2) Bookouture The Next Girl: A gripping crime thriller with a heart-stopping twist (Detective Gina Harte Book 1) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense THE HOUSE OF MYSTERY an addictive crime thriller full of twists (Ellie McEwan Book 3) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense THE HOUSE OF MYSTERY an addictive crime thriller full of twists (Ellie McEwan Book 3) Audible The Spectre of Hawthorne Manor: The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series, Book 2 Audible The Spectre of Hawthorne Manor: The Homefront Sleuths Cozy Mystery Series, Book 2 Redglare Media Homicide at the Haunted House (Nightmare, Arizona Paranormal Cozy Mysteries Book 1) Redglare Media Homicide at the Haunted House (Nightmare, Arizona Paranormal Cozy Mysteries Book 1) Tortuga Publishing, LLC The Nikki Garcia Mystery Series: A Box Set of Gripping International Mystery and Crime Tortuga Publishing, LLC The Nikki Garcia Mystery Series: A Box Set of Gripping International Mystery and Crime Mortal Proof: A British Village Cozy Mystery (The Morning Bell Mysteries Book 4) Mortal Proof: A British Village Cozy Mystery (The Morning Bell Mysteries Book 4) Welcome Home to Murder: Book One - The Molly McGuire Cozy Mysteries (Molly McGuire Mysteries 1) Fiona Grace Thistlewood Manor: Murder at the Hedgerow (An Eliza Montagu Cozy Mystery Book 1) Into the Old Town (A Short Story Psychological Thriller): A vacation gone wrong travel thriller set in Greece (Deadly De Thomas & Mercer The Body in the Dales (Yorkshire Murder Mysteries Book 1) Thomas & Mercer The Body in the Dales (Yorkshire Murder Mysteries Book 1) Cashmere Conspiracy (A Hazel Stitchworth Cozy Mystery—Book 1) Audible An Aura of Mystery: Ellie McEwan Mysteries, Book 1 Audible An Aura of Mystery: Ellie McEwan Mysteries, Book 1 Double Time Books Non-Suspicious: A Detective Brook Deelman Mystery (Brook Deelman Mysteries Book 1) Winter Solstice Murders: Magpie Cove Cozy Mysteries Book 1 Winter Solstice Murders: Magpie Cove Cozy Mysteries Book 1 Westmacott Press Grave Reviews: A Penthouse for Pets Mystery (The Penthouse for Pets Mysteries Book 5) Westmacott Press Grave Reviews: A Penthouse for Pets Mystery (The Penthouse for Pets Mysteries Book 5) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense Murder Most Bookish: A gripping cozy English crime mystery full of twists (The Chiltern Hills Mysteries Book 1) Joffe Books cozy crime thriller, mystery and suspense Murder Most Bookish: A gripping cozy English crime mystery full of twists (The Chiltern Hills Mysteries Book 1) Undertow: A Cozy Small Town Mystery (Harborview Cafe Mysteries Book 8) Undertow: A Cozy Small Town Mystery (Harborview Cafe Mysteries Book 8) 31% Off Penguin Everyone On This Train Is A Suspect: Can you solve the cleverest murder mystery of the year? Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense DEATH IN KING’S LYNN: A chilling British crime mystery (The Norfolk Coast Murders Book 2) Joffe Books crime thriller, mystery and suspense DEATH IN KING’S LYNN: A chilling British crime mystery (The Norfolk Coast Murders Book 2) The Overdue Warning: A Cozy Mystery of Hidden Notes, Storytime Secrets, and a Killer in Plain Sight (Cozy Mysteries)